What to Do If You Get a Book You Already Have

One of the most common concerns families have when signing up for a book subscription with a replacement option is, “What happens if we already own one of the books?” At Owl Post Books, we understand that avid readers and well-stocked bookshelves can lead to the occasional duplicate. That’s why we’ve made it easy to make sure your subscription remains exciting and fresh—no matter what’s already in your collection.

Owl Post Books is proud to be one of the few children’s book subscription services that offer free replacements. If you receive a book you already have, you can simply reach out to our customer service team. We’ll happily accept returns and send a new title your way. It’s just one of the many ways we work to make our monthly book boxes for kids stress-free and family-friendly.

Our commitment to customer happiness goes beyond just great stories—we also offer exceptional flexibility. Whether you need to change the age range of your subscription or make a one-time gift purchase, our team is ready to help. This level of care is especially important for gift-givers like grandparents and long-distance family members, who want to ensure every delivery feels personal and perfect.

Choosing a book subscription with replacement option also provides peace of mind to parents. You won’t have to worry about collecting extra copies of the same title. Instead, you’ll continue building a diverse, high-quality home library filled with fresh stories and exciting new reads. That means more chances for your child to fall in love with reading, and fewer unused books gathering dust.

At Owl Post Books, our mission is to provide screen-free, literacy-rich experiences that grow with your child. From board books for babies to YA fantasy fiction for teens, every box is curated with care. And if something’s not quite right? We’ll make it right—because we believe reading should always be a joyful journey.